Can a paper be accepted without review?

As stated previously, it is very rare that a paper will be accepted without any form of revisions requested. It is the job of the editor and reviewer to make sure that the published papers are scientifically sound, factual, clear and complete.

Can a paper be accepted without peer review?

Answer: Many journals do not have a peer review process for certain article types, for instance, short communications or letters to the editor. These articles are usually published based on the editor's evaluation and decision.

Why was my paper rejected without review?

Sometimes, papers are desk rejected based on their poor writing, with sentences difficult to understand, or simply because they mix methods, results, and discussion or lack reporting essential components of the research.

How often are papers accepted without revision?

It is uncommon for a paper to be accepted for publication without changes – most papers are revised at least once in light of comments from reviewers and editors.

Can an accepted paper be rejected?

Once a paper has been accepted for publication in a journal, can the author(s) still reject it? Yes, the authors can withdraw the paper, not reject it, by explaining to the Journal the reason behind it. That is called voluntary retraction.

5 reasons why 80% of research papers get rejected without a review | What to do instead?

Why would a paper be rejected?

– the statistics are inadequate; – the data have been interpreted poorly; – the analysis is weak; or – the paper duplicates other work/does not report on anything new. A paper may be rejected because of problems with its presentation.

How do you say paper is accepted but not published?

Once the manuscript has been accepted for publication, cite it as an in-press article” (APA, 2020, p. 337). “A manuscript submitted for publication is not available to the public. If the manuscript is available online, treat it as informally published” (APA, 2020, p.

Does minor revision mean accepted?

Accept with minor revisions (acceptance): The journal will publish the paper and asks the author to make small corrections. This is typically the best outcome that authors should hope for.

Do papers get rejected after revisions?

If you deal with the major revisions the right way, you can get published. And you can still be rejected after major revisions; therefore, you need to take particular care.

Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?

If two reviewers cannot agree on whether to accept or reject a paper, then a third review can be sought. It's unusual to have a rejection after minor revisions. Unless you were antagonistic in your approach to the reviewers, I would suspect the possibility of an administrative error.

What is reject without review?

For instance, the editor may judge that the paper is not one that belongs to the topic or the field that the journal will publish. As such, It will then be a waste of time having the paper peer-reviewed. The author is then informed of rejection without review by the editor.

How long should it take to review a paper?

In general, this should take you around a full working day. How long this exactly becomes depends on: The level and clarity of the paper (very bad paper takes less time, mediocre paper takes more time, very good paper takes less time). Your familiarity with the subject (less familiar more time).

Is review paper important?

The purpose of a review paper is to succinctly review recent progress in a particular topic. Overall, the paper summarizes the current state of knowledge of the topic. It creates an understanding of the topic for the reader by discussing the findings presented in recent research papers.

Can an editor accept the paper without sending it to review?

In cases where the work was felt to be of high quality, papers can sometimes be accepted without further review, but if there were serious criticisms, the Editors will consider them in making the decision.

Do all journals accept review papers?

There are some journals that only publish review articles, and others that do not accept them. Make sure you check the aims and scope of the journal you'd like to publish in to find out if it's the right place for your review article.

What if a paper is not peer reviewed?

Non-peer reviewed articles make it incredibly accessible for writers of all levels to publish their own work. However, this also brings about its own issues. With no formal review process, it means that authors can publish misleading or bad-quality research.

Do most journals accept re submission of rejected papers?

This depends on the type and severity of the rejection, as well as the scope and quality of your work. If the rejection was based on minor or moderate issues that can be fixed easily, you may consider resubmitting to the same journal, especially if it is a high-impact or prestigious one.

How common is revise and resubmit?

Getting a revise and resubmit request from a journal may be unnerving, but it is the most common recommendation by peer reviewers across disciplines.

Can I resubmit a manuscript after rejection?

While there are multiple options for researchers after manuscript rejection, most usually choose to prepare a revised manuscript and work to submit it either in the same or different journal.

How often are major revisions accepted?

For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly between 80-90%. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it just seems downright unfair to reject the paper.

Do major revisions go back to reviewers?

Major revisions are almost always sent back to reviewers for a re-review to determine whether the comments have been addressed and no new comments are raised.

What is the difference between major revision and reject and resubmit?

Some journals use the term "revise & resubmit" or "reject & resubmit" instead of "major revision". These are all the same thing: they all mean that your paper is not accepted now but you're getting a chance to revise it and get it reviewed again.

How long after a paper is accepted is it published?

The final step is an internal proofread to ensure the quality of the paper that is going for publication. In summary, it takes about 4-6 weeks after acceptance for a paper to be published (faster for fast-tracked papers).

Is accepted paper considered published?

The accepted manuscript is the version that has gone through peer-review. The content should be the same as the final published version, but it shouldn't include any copy-editing, typesetting or copyright marking from the publisher.

What does it mean when a paper is accepted?

Once the paper is accepted, it is forwarded to the production team for formatting, editing and proofreading. The final proof of the paper is sent to the authors for verification. The authors have to verify the proof for grammatical and technical errors. Finally, the paper is published online.