Can an editor reject a paper?

Yes, it is possible for an editor to reject an article before it goes through the peer review process. When you submit an article to a journal or publication, the editor typically conducts an initial review to assess its suitability for the journal's scope, content, quality, and adherence to the journal's guidelines.

Why do editors reject manuscripts?

Editorial reasons for rejection include: Out of scope for the journal. Not enough of an advance or of enough impact for the journal. Research ethics ignored such as consent from patients or approval from an ethics committee for animal research.

Can associate editor reject a paper?

Once an AE has agreed to handle a paper, then they are responsible for reading the submission, assigning reviewers, evaluating the reviews, and making a recommendation for the acceptance or rejection of the paper.

Is it normal for paper to be rejected?

According to European Science Editing, the average rejection rate of research papers across different disciplines is 80%. Research paper rejection is the process of rejecting a submitted manuscript by a journal editor or reviewer based on its quality, relevance, originality, or other criteria.

Can a reviewer reject a paper?

The reviewer's main job is to give objective feedback. The decision whether to reject is subjective and it's up to the editor, not the reviewer. An erroneous paper won't be published but the editor may always decide to give you a chance to fix those errors.

5 reasons why 80% of research papers get rejected without a review | What to do instead?

How common is journal rejection?

However, it may not be appreciated by editors and reviewers when the research is submitted to a journal for publication. One should not get disappointed by rejections. Most top journals have almost 80% rejection rates.

Can an editor review a paper?

Editorial review is also a part of the peer-review process. Typically editors will take a first pass at an article to determine if it's worthwhile to send out for peer review. They will typically evaluate if the article is: Within the journal's scope.

Do papers get rejected after revisions?

If you deal with the major revisions the right way, you can get published. And you can still be rejected after major revisions; therefore, you need to take particular care.

Why was my paper rejected without review?

Sometimes, papers are desk rejected based on their poor writing, with sentences difficult to understand, or simply because they mix methods, results, and discussion or lack reporting essential components of the research.

How often do manuscripts get rejected?

As you may have read in the article on desk rejection, depending on the journal, between 40%–75% of submitted manuscripts receive desk rejection. Those 25%–60% of manuscripts that make the initial cut are then sent out for peer review.

Can you be a good writer but a bad editor?

The Takeaway

I believe that being a writer yourself gives you an advantage as an editor, but great writing and great editing are two separate skill sets. A great writer can be a terrible editor, and a great editor doesn't have to be a writer at all.

What does an editor not do?

Editors are not responsible for changing your story. Our job is to offer suggestions with the goal of helping you make your manuscript the best it can be. Many authors are afraid of working with editors because of a misconception that we will rip their story to shreds and change their voice.

Can a letter to the editor agree with an article?

Beyond that, your letter can agree or disagree with the ideas expressed in the essay or article. And feel free to be creative with your language and writing style. Use the letters you read earlier as examples of what makes a great letter to the editor.

What to do if your paper is rejected?

How long does a paper stay with editor?

On average, the length of time it takes an editor to process a paper submitted to their journal and send it out for peer review is 2-3 weeks.

Can a publisher steal my manuscript?

Firstly, reputable publishers and agents are not in the business of 'stealing' work. They are inundated with plenty of writers with plenty of ideas and if yours has potential then rest assured the agent or publisher will be interested in you and your work.

Do most journals accept resubmission of rejected papers?

Getting a manuscript rejected by a journal can be a frustrating and discouraging experience. However, rejection does not mean that your work is worthless or that you should give up on your research. In many cases, you can resubmit your manuscript to the same or a different journal, with some revisions and improvements.

How do you say paper is accepted but not published?

Once the manuscript has been accepted for publication, cite it as an in-press article” (APA, 2020, p. 337). “A manuscript submitted for publication is not available to the public. If the manuscript is available online, treat it as informally published” (APA, 2020, p.

What is the difference between major revisions and reject?

Wherein an editor rejects an article but invites you to resubmit later, presumably with what is basically major revisions. Response: Reject and resubmits are situations where the manuscript is rejected, but unlike 'reject' these manuscripts can be modified and resubmitted if appropriate.

How common are major revisions?

Getting a “major revisions” decision is quite common. In fact, if you don't get a desk reject, then major revisions is the most common decision to expect.

How often are major revisions accepted?

For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly between 80-90%. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it just seems downright unfair to reject the paper.

Can an editor review a paper himself?

Of course, he can. An editor can “review” anything he wants. What happens to a manuscript after that all depends upon the publisher, its goals and scope, its policies, and the job description of its editors. Some publications (particularly trade periodicals) have no set reviewer policy.

What does an editor do for a paper?

Editors plan, coordinate, and revise material for publication in books, newspapers, or periodicals or on websites. Editors review story ideas and decide what material will appeal most to readers. During the review process, editors offer comments to improve the product and suggest titles and headlines.

Is reviewed the same as editor?

Reviewers have a much more limited role than editors. A reviewer can only view a manuscript that they have been specifically invited to review. They also cannot make a publication decision - they can only write a review and recommend the publication decision.

Why do journals reject papers?

A journal will also reject your paper if they feel that you're not keeping up well enough with the ongoing research in your field. They think that, if you don't know and showcase what other researchers are doing, or have done, in the field, you might have missed important developments that could affect your research.