Do editors use suggested reviewers?

The editors will not necessarily invite your suggested reviewers but these suggestions can help speed up the peer review process. Top tips for suggesting reviewers: Suggest people in your field whose view of your paper you would respect.

How do editors pick reviewers?

The editor should select someone who has a good track record of fair reviews returned promptly, who can review the manuscript without professional or personal bias, and without potential conflict of interest.

What is the difference between an editor and a peer reviewer?

What is the difference between peer review and paper editing? To put it shortly, paper editing is reading and evaluating a manuscript and providing constructive feedback for your journal article. A peer review is a review done by more or less independent scholars of the same field to assess the quality of work.

Can an editor also be a reviewer?

Traditionally, editors recruit peer reviewers and, based on their input, make a decision about the fate of a paper. Once a submission is sent for in-depth peer review, however, the Reviewing Editor at eLife has extra responsibility. First, the Reviewing Editor is expected to serve as one of the peer reviewers.

Can editor accept paper without peer review?

In cases where the work was felt to be of high quality, papers can sometimes be accepted without further review, but if there were serious criticisms, the Editors will consider them in making the decision.

How to search for reviewers on Editorial Manager using author-suggested reviewers

What percent of peer review submissions are rejected?

As you may have read in the article on desk rejection, depending on the journal, between 40%–75% of submitted manuscripts receive desk rejection.

Why was my paper rejected without review?

Sometimes, papers are desk rejected based on their poor writing, with sentences difficult to understand, or simply because they mix methods, results, and discussion or lack reporting essential components of the research.

How many reviewers does an editor typically send a manuscript to to review?

The handling editor sends invitations to individuals he or she believes would be appropriate reviewers. As responses are received, further invitations are issued, if necessary, until the required number of reviewers is secured– commonly this is 2, but there is some variation between journals.

Can an editor review a paper himself?

Of course, he can. An editor can “review” anything he wants. What happens to a manuscript after that all depends upon the publisher, its goals and scope, its policies, and the job description of its editors. Some publications (particularly trade periodicals) have no set reviewer policy.

What should an editor not do?

You can also make changes to certain extent to improve readability, if it is so required. But, you should not make changes in a way that the original copy does not exist at all. Remember, the writer writes; that's why you are the editor.

Do editors do peer review?

The peer review process is a fundamental part of research publishing. It's a way of ensuring only articles of the highest quality, which describe sound research methods and results, are published. The process involves both the journal editors and independent expert reviewers, who evaluate the submitted articles.

Do editors of Frontiers get paid?

Chief editors receive an honorarium if their section or field reaches certain submission levels and for their editorial project work. The honorarium is not based on the number of accepted articles, ensuring that editors have no incentive to accept manuscripts.

What role does an editor usually play in the peer review process?

An editor in chief can improve the peer review process by choosing good reviewers; helping reviewers make good choices in selecting articles for a journal; and facilitating positive, productive communication between reviewers and authors.

Who are suggested reviewers?

Suggest researchers who know the subject well and are willing to invest the time ('big names' will often decline) Consider the diversity of your suggested reviewers with regards to the following characteristics: gender, ethnicity, career stage and geographical location.

What are the rules for suggesting reviewers?

How many reviewers usually see a paper?

A minimum of two independent reviewers is normally required for every research article. The aims and scope of each journal will outline their peer review policy in detail. The reviewers will be asked to read and comment on your article.

What if a journal can't find reviewers?

Some journals ask authors to provide a list of potential peer reviewers; however they must not be from the same institution/research group as the author and they must not have published together—this must be made clear in the instructions to authors information.

How long does a paper stay with editor?

On average, the length of time it takes an editor to process a paper submitted to their journal and send it out for peer review is 2-3 weeks.

Should you hire an editor for self publishing?

Yes, you can go without hiring an editor.

However, you must find a quality editor once you have created and published your first book and want to start writing more books. This is essential because this person will take your books to the next level.

What is the going rate for editing a manuscript?

Line editing rates for your manuscript usually cost between $. 04 and $. 09 per word. Some copy editors charge by manuscript page, in the range of $5 to $15 per page.

How long does it take an editor to read a manuscript?

A Rough Editing Timeline

Each round of editing by the editing team itself can take between two to four weeks to complete. There can be multiple rounds of content editing before a manuscript is ready to move on to copy editing.

How long does editor review take?

Editorial Decisions

The handling Academic Editor or staff editor makes the final decision on each manuscript. The time to render a first decision averages about 43 days, but times vary depending on how long it takes for the editor to receive and assess reviews.

Do papers ever get accepted without revision?

It is uncommon for a paper to be accepted for publication without changes – most papers are revised at least once in light of comments from reviewers and editors. When a revised paper is received: Minor changes will usually be assessed directly by the editor.

Do most journals accept resubmission of rejected papers?

Getting a manuscript rejected by a journal can be a frustrating and discouraging experience. However, rejection does not mean that your work is worthless or that you should give up on your research. In many cases, you can resubmit your manuscript to the same or a different journal, with some revisions and improvements.

Why do editors reject manuscripts?

Improper manuscript uploading in the journals' author center (this may add to the frustration of the Editor-in-Chief) Missing covering letter or with improper authors' affiliations. Improper formatting and language, grammatical lapses, and typographic errors.