Do minor revisions go back to reviewers?

Answer: If the minor revision were requested by the reviewers (instead of the editors) the editors will send the manuscript back to the reviewers to confirm requested revisions were adequately incorporated.

Do revisions go back to reviewers?

Minor changes will usually be assessed directly by the editor. If significant revisions were requested, the editor will usually return the manuscript to the original reviewers (unless they opted out of this)

What are the chances of acceptance after minor revision?

For first and second resubmissions, 40.0–55.2% of manuscripts representing a Major Revision and 91.5–94.7% of manuscripts representing a Minor Revision were accepted; 100% of manuscripts undergoing a third resubmission were accepted; 98.3% and 84.7% of manuscripts receiving at first submission a decision of Minor ...

Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?

If two reviewers cannot agree on whether to accept or reject a paper, then a third review can be sought. It's unusual to have a rejection after minor revisions. Unless you were antagonistic in your approach to the reviewers, I would suspect the possibility of an administrative error.

How long does it take to get a decision after minor revisions?

For a minor revision, the editor may decide to send the revised manuscript to the peer reviewer for a final check or review the manuscript themselves if the changes were indeed minor. Based on this, it may take about two-three weeks for this round of review and for the final decision.

On Peer Reviewing: "Accepting with Major Revisions" vs. "Reject"

What does accepted with minor revisions mean?

Minor Revision - A limited number of changes are required. Implies that the editors and reviewers feel the paper is publishable once their comments have been addressed. Examples: Some re-writing is needed to address specific areas where the manuscript is ambiguous and requires clarity.

What is reviewers assigned after minor revision?

For papers accepted after minor revision, the revised papers are often published without another full process of peer review. The authors can still be asked for explanations for certain points raised by the referees if they had not been adequately addressed.

What is the difference between minor revision and revise and resubmit?

Typically authors are given a deadline for submitting revisions. Minor revision might be a few weeks, major revisions might be a month or two. If an editor thinks authors need more time than a major revision decision would allow, they should use the “revise and resubmit” option.

What are the chances of acceptance after major revision?

Accept with minor revisions had a 67% acceptance rate, whereas accept with major revisions had a 40% acceptance rate.

Can paper be rejected after second revision?

Answer: Unfortunately, sometimes manuscript do get rejected after the second or even third round of revisions. This can happen due to multiple reasons such as: The authors might not have adequately addressed all the questions raised by the reviewers.

What is the difference between major and minor revisions?

"Major revision" usually is something that requires new research (e.g., collecting more data, running a second study, or doing some complicated new analysis), unlike "minor revision" which is usually just changing the writing within the paper.

Does a paper get accepted after major revision?

If you deal with the major revisions the right way, you can get published. And you can still be rejected after major revisions; therefore, you need to take particular care.

What is recommended publication with minor revision?

Minor revisions are recommended for manuscripts which make a clear and sound contribution, but require a few small changes to ensure it is fully fit for publication. This usually includes textual changes based on clarification of minor points or sentences, abbreviations, minor revision to figures for clarity.

How do you respond to a minor revision?

If the editor indicates that your paper is accepted with minor revisions – celebrate! Your paper will be published. Accept the changes the reviewers request and re-submit with a letter indicating exactly how you have responded to each of the reviewers suggestions and a letter to the editor thanking him /her.

What is awaiting reviewer scores after minor revision?

"Awaiting Reviewer Scores" means that the paper has been assigned the minimum amount of reviewers that the Associate Editor has set for the manuscript. The minimum would be either two or three depending on the publication but the associate editor might have sent a few more invitations around.

What is the rejection rate for Elsevier?

When a manuscript is submitted to a high-quality scholarly journal, it goes through intense scrutiny — even before it's seen by the editor-in-chief and selected for peer review. At Elsevier, between 30 percent to 50 percent of articles don't even make it to the peer review process.

How common are major revisions?

Getting a “major revisions” decision is quite common. In fact, if you don't get a desk reject, then major revisions is the most common decision to expect. So, while you may feel beaten down by seven pages of comments from reviewers, know that a “major revisions” decision is a pathway towards improvement.

Is getting a revise and resubmit good?

If this is the case, the editor will invite you to revise and resubmit your work. In doing so, they are indicating to you that they see value in your research, but want to see some significant changes prior to acceptance.

How long to review after major revision?

Usually reviewers are given 3 months to review a manuscript which has been rendered a "major revision" decision. Since the status shows "Under Review", it means that your manuscript is with the reviewer. So keep your fingers crossed and hopefully you will hear from the journal soon.

What are the 3 stages of revision?

There are three steps to the revision process: revising, editing and proofreading. It is also important to remember that time management is a key factor in the complete process of researching, writing and editing your work.

What is provisional accept with minor revision?

Provisional Acceptance - The manuscript is provisionally accepted. Minor or major revision - In cases where the editors determine that the authors should be able to address the referees' concerns in a month or less the editors may request a revised manuscript that addresses concerns.

What are the three R's of revision?

ERIC - EJ435685 - The 3 R's of Revision: Review, Reread, React/Reshape., Writing Notebook: Creative Word Processing in the Classroom, 1991. The 3 R's of Revision: Review, Reread, React/Reshape.

What is editor assigned after minor revision?

Answer: After two revisions (the first major and the second minor), the Editor Assigned status means that the manuscript is with the Associate Editor (AE) to review the second round of changes and also the manuscript as a whole.

Can a paper be rejected after major revision?

If you deal with the major revisions the right way, you can get published. And you can still be rejected after major revisions; therefore, you need to take particular care.

What is the difference between revisions required and resubmit for review?

Revisions Required: The submission will be accepted after minor changes have been made. Resubmit for Review: The submission needs to be re-worked, but with significant changes, may be accepted. It will require a second round of review, however.