How do you deal with predatory journals?

If a submitted paper has been accepted by a predatory journal, you should never sign a copyright agreement with the journal or publisher. In some cases, writing to the journal to withdraw the submitted or accepted manuscript before its publication may also be successful.

What to do if you submit to a predatory journal?

What happens if you publish in predatory journal?

If you publish your research in a predatory journal, you face these potential consequences: Damage to your reputation and career. Wasted time, effort, and money. Loss of your research and scholarship.

What are the most common complaints of predatory publications?

What is the predatory journal policy?

Predatory journals typically have no editors and publish content exactly as submitted without any editorial review, and most are in English even if that is not the native language of the country of origin. Because of this, you'll often find that they're rife with errors.

The Problem of Predatory Journals

Are all paid journals predatory?

No, there are other types. For example, predatory journals may steal intellectual property through deception, engage in fraudulent or fake peer review, or list respected researchers on its editorial board without their knowledge or consent.

Who are the victims of predatory journals?

First-time authors are particularly vulnerable because they may be unaware of these journals, but experienced authors have been victims as well. Here's what you need to know about predatory journals and how to protect yourself.

What are the consequences of predatory publishing?

Deleterious Effects of Predatory Publishing

It also puts at risk the cumulative nature of science. The fraudulent research and erroneous findings get into scientific literature and circulation. The enormous amount of money of funding bodies is wasted. The trust of the public in research and science is wasted.

Is Frontiers a predatory publisher?

In 2015, Frontiers Media was classified as a possible predatory publisher by Jeffrey Beall, though Beall's list was taken offline two years later in a decision that remains controversial.

Which of the following is a red flag for identifying a predatory journal?

Unclear or deceptive publishing fees and copyright policies. Fake names are listed on the editorial staff. Names of prominent scholars are included as editors without the knowledge or consent of these individuals. Published articles are plagiarized, completely fake, are scientifically unsound, or low quality.

Why do authors publish in predatory journals?

Studies looking at why authors might be tempted to engage with predatory publishers identified several factors that likely influence their decisions. Push factors: pressure to publish to meet institutional expectations or funding requirements. fear of career stagnation or job loss if publishing targets are not met.

How do you identify predatory publishing?

Should I destroy my journals?

Read through one old journal a week. If it's full of entries that will do you no good, or is a reminder of a sad or bad part of your life, toss it in the recycle bin or have a bonfire/journal burning party. Who wants all that negativity stored so closely? Do away with it forever.

How do I file a complaint against a journal?

The complaint should in first instance be handled by the Editor-in-Chief(s) responsible for the journal and/or the Editor who handled the paper. If they are the subject of the complaint please approach the in-house publishing contact. (Please check the contacts page on the journal homepage.

Should you cite predatory journals?

They recommend avoiding citations from the predatory journals as by citing articles from these journals; authors share information that may not be credible and validated for use by other researchers and clinicians. Dadkhah et al. labeled papers published in predatory and hijacked journals as questionable [3].

Is predatory publishing illegal?

Although predatory publishing is exploitative and unethical, if the publisher is engaging in illegal behavior needs to be evaluated on a case by case basis. If and which journal is predatory is sometimes disputable and the best thing you can do is just not engage with a journal if you think it is predatory.

Which is better MDPI or Frontiers?

There are some differences though. For example, Frontiers publishes papers fast, but slower than MDPI, it has a higher reliance on the Chinese market than MDPI, it charges higher APCs than MDPI, and its journals are slightly better ranked than those of MDPI.

Is Frontiers a predatory journal 2023?

Frontiers has been listed on a misinformation website called predatoryreports.org. The website's ownership and purpose are deliberately unclear, and the information provided both in its blog and journal listings is incorrect.

Who publishes in predatory journals?

Those who publish in “predatory” journals are, for the most part, young and inexperienced researchers from developing countries. We believe that economic and sociocultural conditions in these developing countries have contributed to the differences found in authorship between “predatory” and “nonpredatory” journals.

Can a publisher steal your manuscript?

It is rare for a publisher to steal a manuscript, but it is not rare for people to steal your work online. If you publish your work on the web, there is a genuine chance that someone might decide to take your writing. Usually, this will consist of someone republishing a story or a poem in their name.

Is it alright to use predatory journals in a research paper?

It may be tempting for authors to submit to these journals, particularly if they are not aware that it may be a scam, or if they are in a hurry to be published⁴. However, submitting articles to predatory journals may have serious negative consequences such as the ones listed below.

Can you sue a publisher?

A publisher could be found liable for negligent publication if the publisher's publication contains instructions, advise or other information that contains errors or defects or fails to warn the reader of inherent dangers, and the reader by using or acting upon such instructions, advise or other information is injured, ...

Is PubMed a predatory journal?

PubMed, MEDLINE and PubMed Central are all funded by the National Library of Medicine but are different databases. PubMed has been reported to include some articles published in predatory journals.

Why is MDPI a predatory journal?

Allegation of anomalous citation patterns

The alleged high self-citation rate is not to other articles in the same journal, but rather to other MDPI journals. Oviedo-García argued that this is indicative of predatory journals. MDPI released a response to Oviedo-García's paper on their website eight days later.

What is the difference between predatory journals and serious journals?

Because predatory publishers do not follow the proper academic standards for publishing, they usually offer a quick turnaround on publishing a manuscript. In contrast, high quality academic journals take longer to publish articles because they go through a proper peer review and copy editing process.