How does Luther Standing Bear description of the Carlisle School compared to Ellis children's description?

Final answer: Luther Standing Bear's description of Carlisle School is more negative, documenting oppression and forced assimilation. On the other hand, Ellis Childers presents a balanced perspective, acknowledging the hardships but also recognizing the school's educational goals.

What was the purpose of the Carlisle School based on Luther Standing Bear?

Built in a former military barracks by Lieutenant Richard Henry Pratt, Carlisle served as an important model for Indian education during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. As Standing Bear, a Sioux, explains, Carlisle's goal was to strip Indians of their cultural heritage and educate them in the ways of whites.

What were some of the changes that the Carlisle teachers forced Luther Standing Bear and his fellow students to make?

The Carlisle teachers forced Luther Standing Bear and his fellow students to make several changes. Some of these changes included cutting their hair short, wearing European-style clothing, and speaking only English.

What was distinctive about the Carlisle Boarding School?

The school assigned his father's name, Standing Bear, as his surname. The children were forced to change their manner of dress and to give up their traditional tribal ways. The boys all had long hair, which was a strong tradition in their cultures: it was cut short in Euro-American style.

What was children's tone regarding the teachers at Carlisle?

Childers's tone towards the teachers at Carlisle was critical and he provided evidence to support his claim that they were not adequately meeting the needs of their Indigenous students. In the document "The Indian Schools", Childers's tone towards the teachers at Carlisle was critical and judgmental.

Luther Standing Bear

What is the tone of the school?

Your school's tone is how that personality is communicated.

Your school's tone is what makes your school's voice relevant and appropriate in all situations. It can change depending on what and to whom you are trying to communicate, but it always reflects your school's personality.

How does the description of the carlisle indian industrial school in document c compare with the description in document b?

Differences: 1.In document B, they wanted to kill the indian and save the man, while in Document C they described the school as a place for native indian kids to learn english and be taught by their teachers.

Why was the Carlisle School bad?

Some never made it back home. The purpose of Carlisle, as well as other boarding schools across the nation, was to remove Native Americans from their cultures and lifestyles and assimilate them into the white man's society.

What are some interesting facts about Carlisle School?

The United States founded the Carlisle school in 1879 at the site of an old military base, used during the colonial era and the Civil War. Soldiers also used it as an army training school from 1838 to 1871. The same buildings were used for the Indian Industrial School.

What is one reason why so many native students died at boarding schools like Carlisle?

Boarding schools were susceptible to deadly infections like tuberculosis and the flu, and schools like Carlisle had cemeteries for dead students. Between Carlisle's founding 1879 and its closing 1918, the school buried nearly 200 children in its cemetery.

Is Carlisle Indian School still standing?

It was housed in Carlisle, PA at the Carlisle Barracks, now the home of the U.S. Army War College. "Carlisle" became the model for 24 off reservation schools with the purpose of acculturation. Many of the school buildings are still standing.

How many died at Carlisle Indian School?

More than 180 Native children died at Carlisle, often from a combination of malnourishment, sustained abuse and disease brought on by poor living conditions.

How were Pratt's goals for the Carlisle School similar to previous federal policies of removing Native American tribes from their lands and waging war against them?

Explanation: Pratt's goals for the Carlisle School were similar to previous federal policies of removing Native American tribes from their lands and waging war against them in that they both aimed at assimilating Native Americans into mainstream American culture.

What was Luther standing bear known for?

Standing Bear was at the forefront of the Progressive movement and his commentaries educated the American public, deepened awareness and created popular support to change government policies toward Native American peoples.

What type of school was the Carlisle School?

Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, opened in 1879 as the first government-run boarding school for Native American children. The goal? Forced assimilation of Native children into white American society under the belief of “Kill the Indian, Save the Man.”

How were the children at the Carlisle School treated?

The children were forced to cut their hair and give up their traditional clothing. They had to give up their meaningful Native names and take English ones. They were not only taught to speak English but were punished for speaking their own languages.

Was the Carlisle School successful?

By some measures the Carlisle school was a success. During the school's 39-year history more than 10,000 students attended.

Was the Carlisle Indian School good or bad?

Historian Cary Collins explores the conditions of the Carlisle Indian School and other Native American Boarding schools in her book “The Broken Crucible of Assimilation.” Collins argues that the poor conditions of these boarding schools, the lack of school funding, and the understaffing of these schools, and the ...

What is special about Carlisle?

Carlisle is the only city in Cumbria. The city centre is largely pedestrianised and the Lanes shopping centre is home to around 75 shops. Carlisle has a compact historic centre with a castle, cathedral and semi-intact city walls, as well as other medieval buildings including the Guildhall and Tithe Barn.

Which was the harshest punishment at the Carlisle School?

Students were forced to cut their hair, change their names, stop speaking their Native languages, convert to Christianity, and endure harsh discipline including corporal punishment and solitary confinement.

How did the Carlisle school end?

The Carlisle Indian School was officially transferred to the Department of War on September 1, 1918, for use as U.S. Army Base Hospital #31. The entire closure process occurred between July 9 and September 1, 1918, during which time the majority of the included documents were created.

How many students died at Carlisle boarding school?

Richard Pratt, who started the boarding school that housed indigenous children from across the U.S. including South Dakota. The school opened in 1879 and closed in 1918. About 200 children died at the school. According to the U.S. National Library of Medicine, “…

What impact did the Carlisle School have on Native American culture?

Carlisle and other off-reservation boarding schools instituted their assault on Native cultural identity by first doing away with all outward signs of tribal life that the children brought with them. The long braids worn by Indian boys were cut off. The children were made to wear standard uniforms.

What phrase best describes the practice of boarding schools such as the Carlisle Indian School in Pennsylvania?

“Kill the Indian in him, and save the man.” That was the mindset under which the U.S. government forced tens of thousands of Native American children to attend “assimilation” boarding schools in the late 19th century.

Why was the Carlisle Indian School shut down?

World War I was used as one reason for Carlisle to close, being it was formally used for military training and was used for that again once the school closed its doors. But the closure, in the broad spectrum, was widely symbolic.