How many reviewers does an editor typically send a manuscript to to review?

If your article is sent out for review, it will generally be sent to between 3-5 reviewers who will be asked to give feedback on the article and advise whether it is suitable for publication.

How many reviewers review a manuscript?

18 Thus, with a commonly used number of three reviewers assigned to each manuscript received, a journal with an 80% rejection rate will need 15 reviewers to complete the task in order to publish one article. 18 Figure 1 provides the shape of the series with two to five reviewers assigned per manuscript received.

How many reviewers usually see a paper in Elsevier?

Most papers receive feedback from three peer reviewers. Shorter papers, such as brief reports or current issues, may receive feedback from two peer reviewers. Some journal submissions such as commentaries and book reviews are reviewed by AJPM editors and do not undergo external peer review.

How long does it take from editor to reviewer?

Journals usually ask reviewers to complete their reviews within 3-4 weeks. However, few journals have a mechanism to enforce the deadline, which is why it can be hard to predict how long the peer review process will take.

Do editors use suggested reviewers?

The editors will not necessarily invite your suggested reviewers but these suggestions can help speed up the peer review process. Top tips for suggesting reviewers: Suggest people in your field whose view of your paper you would respect.

How peer review works? From article submission to publishing

How do editors pick reviewers?

The editor should select someone who has a good track record of fair reviews returned promptly, who can review the manuscript without professional or personal bias, and without potential conflict of interest.

Can editor accept a paper without review?

In cases where the work was felt to be of high quality, papers can sometimes be accepted without further review, but if there were serious criticisms, the Editors will consider them in making the decision.

How long does a manuscript stay with editor?

On average, the length of time it takes an editor to process a paper submitted to their journal and send it out for peer review is 2-3 weeks.

What is the status of with editor for review?

With Editor:

This status indicates that an editor has taken charge of the manuscript. At this stage, the editor completes an initial screening of the manuscript, and if he/she finds it suitable for the journal, it is sent for peer review.

What is the status of manuscript with editor?

Typically, the status "With Editor" is displayed while the manuscript is with the Editor-in-chief or Associate editor before it goes for peer review.

How many peer reviewers are usually invited to review a paper?

The handling editor sends invitations to individuals he or she believes would be appropriate reviewers. As responses are received, further invitations are issued, if necessary, until the required number of reviewers is secured– commonly this is 2, but there is some variation between journals.

How many reviewers review a paper?

This usually involves review by at least two independent, expert peer reviewers. Individual journals may differ in their peer review processes (e.g. open or anonymized), please refer to the specific journal for details.

What is the difference between a reviewer and an editor?

Reviewers are subject matter experts who assess the content itself and provide detailed feedback, while Editors have a broader responsibility for managing the publication process, including selecting and coordinating reviewers, making publication decisions, and ensuring the content aligns with the publication's ...

Can reviewers reject a manuscript?

Your manuscript can be rejected for many reasons but these can generally be divided into technical and editorial reasons. Technical reasons usually require more work such as further experiments or analysis before your work can be published. Technical reasons for rejection include: Incomplete data.

How long should it take to review a manuscript?

Short answer: It takes up to about 3 months (studies have shown peer review typically takes 7–12 weeks), but there are a lot of variables to take into account. These include the journal's internal processes and publication frequency, availability of peer reviewers, and other things out of your control.

Do reviewers of manuscripts get paid?

Researchers are sometimes paid for reviewing books or other written work. However, they are usually not paid for reviewing scientific papers.

What to expect from an editor?

He or she won't write the story for you. Instead, your editor will help you produce the best story you can. Your editor will do this by pointing out opportunities for improvement. By the end of your time together, not only will your manuscript improve, but you should also improve as a storyteller.

What does it mean if the paper is with the editor?

Answer: This stage indicates that your paper has not yet been sent for peer review. As per the normal journal processes, the editor first conducts an initial screening of the manuscript. If the manuscript passes this screening, it is sent for peer review.

How do editors decide on issues to publish?

Editors are responsible for making manuscript decisions based upon reviewer reports and their own reading of the manuscript. In the majority of cases, at least two reports will be received which are broadly in agreement, making it possible to assess reviewer comments easily and reach a straightforward decision.

How often are manuscripts rejected?

About 20-30% of the manuscripts can very quickly be categorized as unsuitable or beyond the scope of the journal. The Editor-in-Chief has the discretion to reject the manuscript straight off even before sending it to the reviewers for reviewing.

How long is the average manuscript?

So here's a real answer: in my work with academic authors, the vast majority of manuscripts fall in the 80,000–90,000-word range. Books that fall on the more social sciencey or media studies side of things may be shorter. It's not unusual for those manuscripts to run 65,000–75,000 words when I get a look at them.

How fast does an editor read?

There are general guidelines set out by the Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA) which suggest that for developmental editing an editor can do 1–5 standard pages an hour (where a standard page is always 250 words), heavy copy-editing can be done in 2–5 standard pages per hour, basic copy-editing in 5–10 standard ...

Do minor revisions go back to reviewers?

Minor revisions explained

An editorial decision of 'minor revisions' on your paper means that your work will almost certainly not be going back to the original peer reviewers for a further round of comments; indeed this is policy for many journals.

How do you convince an editor to accept your paper?

The cover letter

The cover letter tells the editor who the corresponding author is. Some journals also want you to include a paragraph (a synopsis) about what your paper is about and why it is novel, but do not repeat the title. The cover letter is also the place for you to suggest potential reviewers of your paper.

What does under review mean with editor?

It means that the editor has received the required number of reviews from the peer reviewers and is evaluating them in order to make the final decision to accept, reject, or request revisions based on reviewers' comments. Thank you for your replay sir, Last week on 16/08/2023, status has changed to under review.