What does the status with editor mean?

Typically, the status "With Editor" is displayed while the manuscript is with the Editor-in-chief or Associate editor before it goes for peer review.

How long does a paper stay with editor?

On average, the length of time it takes an editor to process a paper submitted to their journal and send it out for peer review is 2-3 weeks.

What is the difference between decision in process and with editor?

“in process” usually means that the paper is out to reviewers for their comments. “decision in process” usually means that the comments have been received from the reviewers, and the next step is for the editor to synthesize the comments and publication recommendations, and write you a response letter.

What is with editor after review?

If the status of the manuscript shifted after the peer review to “with editor” or “editor assigned,” it means that the manuscript was returned to the Associate Editor, who will peruse reviewers' feedback and make a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief who makes the final decision (i.e., accepting, rejecting or ...

What does the status editor invited mean?

Editor invited - The journal is identifying potential editors for the submission. Under review - The handling editor has begun to invite peer reviewers to evaluate the submission. Required reviews complete - Some or all assigned reviewers have completed their reviews.

Understanding article status in journal portal

What is next step after editor assigned?

If the Editor-in-Chief decides the paper is within the Journal's remit, the paper will be assigned to an Associate Editor. The Associate Editor selects and assigns peer reviewers. This can take some time dependent on the responsiveness and availability of the reviewers selected.

What is the difference between with editor and under review?

For most journals, a status change from "With Editor" to "Under review" would indicate that the paper has cleared the editorial check and has been sent for external peer review. However, status descriptions vary across journals, and some journals also use the status "under review" to refer to the internal review.

How long does with editor status last?

It is perfectly normal for a submission to remain with the editor for over two weeks. The time taken for the different stages varies from journal to journal, but it is not uncommon for the journal system to show a “with editor” status for over a month after submission.

What is the difference between with editor and editor invited?

In various journals the paper is first assigned to Editor in chief (EIC) and status of paper is "with editor". Usually, EiC assign the paper to some associate editor so the status changes to "Editor Invited". When this associate editor accepts this invitation the status changes to "with editor".

How long does editor review take?

Editorial Decisions

The handling Academic Editor or staff editor makes the final decision on each manuscript. The time to render a first decision averages about 43 days, but times vary depending on how long it takes for the editor to receive and assess reviews.

What does editor decision started mean?

1) After submission, the system shows that Manuscript under consideration, which means that it is being evaluated by the editor; 2) If the latest status becomes Editor decision started, it means it has been sent for review (you can also check whether there is reviewer.zip in the file list, if yes, it means it is sent ...

What does editor decision made mean?

An editorial decision is made on the basis of the reviewers' reports and all the other information that the editor has related to that submission, and communicated to the author.

What is decision in process after editor without review?

When you see your research paper in the decision process without under review phase, it is a significant moment in the publication process. This status appears after the initial checks, and it means your paper is no longer under review by peers. Instead, the journal's editorial team evaluates it behind the scenes.

Is it normal that my journal submission is with editor after a month?

The time taken for the different stages in the submission process varies across journals, but it is quite normal for the status to show “With editor” for over a month after initial submission. The reason why this stage can take time is that it is often difficult for the editor to find reviewers.

What does editor assigned mean after under review?

However, if the status returns to "Editor assigned," it means that the feedback received from the reviewers necessitates further revisions or modifications. The task is then passed back to the editor or the person responsible for making the necessary changes based on the feedback received.

Can an editor reject a paper?

About 20-30% of the manuscripts can very quickly be categorized as unsuitable or beyond the scope of the journal. The Editor-in-Chief has the discretion to reject the manuscript straight off even before sending it to the reviewers for reviewing.

Who is above an editor?

A managing editor is a senior member of a newspaper or magazine's management team. They report to the publication's editor in chief and oversee several editors, associate editors and assistant editors.

How do you respond to an editor?

What is the under review status?

Under Review: This status indicates that your paper is currently being evaluated by peer reviewers. Peer review involves experts in the field assessing the quality, validity, and significance of your work. The reviewers provide feedback and recommendations to the journal's editors.

How long does it take for an editor to make an offer?

If an editor is really enthusiastic about your book, it could take just a couple of days (or even less!). Generally, however, editors need to present the book at their weekly editorial meeting and get their team onboard before they can make an offer. This can take time, sometimes a week or more.

What does Elsevier status with editor mean?

Answer: The With Editor status may refer to the handling editor for your paper, known as either the Associate Editor (AE) or the Managing Editor (ME), or the Editor of the journal, known as the Editor-in-Chief (EIC).

What is editor status after decision in process?

Answer: A direct change to Decision Under Process (sometimes, also called Decision in Process) after With Editor means that the editor has had a look at the paper and arrived at a decision on the paper, which is to not send it for peer review.

What does editor assigned mean?

Answer: The Editor Assigned status typically means that your manuscript has cleared the initial check (for basic aspects such as adherence to the journal's guidelines and a scope match) and has now been assigned to an Associate Editor (AE).

Why is my paper under review for so long?

There are several possible reasons for such a delay, e.g., overload of papers under review, difficulty in finding suitable reviewers, and reviewers taking longer than usual owing to their own constraints.

How long does the status remain with editor after initial submission?

If the manuscript passes this screening, it is sent for peer review. The time taken for the different stages in the submission process varies across journals, but it is quite normal for the status to show “With editor” for over a month after initial submission.