What is legacy admission controversy?

That inquiry will examine allegations by three liberal groups that Harvard's practice of showing preference for the relatives of alumni and donors discriminates against Black, Hispanic and Asian applicants in favor of white and wealthy students who are less qualified.

What is the problem with legacy admissions?

In the case of legacy admissions, elite universities are effectively discriminating against less privileged students for the benefit of the wealthy — and some donors are enabling them. Fortunately, some universities have already taken legacy preferences off the table. MIT and Wesleyan, for example.

What is the legacy lawsuit for admissions?

The legacy lawsuit brought against Harvard alleges that children of donors and alumni "are flagged at the outset of [the] admissions process and are granted special solicitude" and "tips." The complaint says 15% of Harvard's admitted students represent both children of donors and legacy families.

Why are legacy admissions still a thing?

It is largely, almost exclusively, done by private colleges and universities. These institutions are able to thrive due to donations from alumni and friends of the college. If you want the well-off alumni to continue to write checks, you admit their children. It's almost entirely done for the money it attracts.

What is the complaint against Harvard legacy admissions?

The complaint argues that the need to end so-called legacy admissions — the practice of giving preferential treatment to the children or other relatives of alumni in college or university admissions — is particularly acute at Harvard after the Supreme Court struck down affirmative action programs at two universities, ...

The Controversy Of Legacy-Based Admissions In Higher Education

Do Ivy Leagues care about legacy?

In short, Ivy League and other top schools typically admit legacies at two to five times their overall admission rates. Among top universities, the University of Notre Dame and Georgetown University are known to weigh legacy status heavily in their application processes.

Does Harvard reject legacies?

Harvard gives preference to applicants who are recruited athletes, legacies, relatives of donors and children of faculty and staff. As a group, they make up less than 5 percent of applicants, but around 30 percent of those admitted each year.

Does Oxford consider legacy admissions?

Legacy admissions do not exist at Oxford, Cambridge or virtually anywhere else globally. It is a distinctly American practice. It sounds unusual and quite unfair. If you compare universities outside of America — even some of the best — there is a stark difference in many dimensions.

Why do universities like legacy students?

The “logic” is that legacy students are most likely to matriculate, most likely to graduate, most likely to be happy with the school, and most likely to donate. They continually support the school. Students are familiar with what their parents do and did, and where they went to school.

Why elite colleges won t give up legacy admissions?

Elite colleges say they prioritize legacies for a few reasons. It helps maintain strong ties with alumni, which assists with donations, networking and a sense of community. When admitted, children of alumni are much more likely to attend — helping with something admissions offices call their yield rate.

Does Yale consider legacy?

Eleven percent of the Yale College class of 2027 are legacies, according to the admissions office's First-Year Class Profile. This number marks a slight decrease in legacy population from the class of 2026, which has 12 percent legacy students, and the class of 2025, which has 14 percent legacy students.

Is legacy admissions fair?

Just 30% of college students say that legacy admissions practices are fair. Overall, 32% agree that legacy admissions could have helped their chances of getting into the college of their choice versus the 46% who say the practice may have hurt their chances.

Do public universities care about legacy?

After the Varsity Blues scandal, California lawmakers approved a bill that required all universities receiving state funding to submit annual reports on whether they practice legacy admissions. The state's public universities do not consider legacy in admissions, but many of the private ones do.

Which universities do not consider legacy?

What are the disadvantages of being a legacy student?

The bigger drawback is that legacy admissions tend to reenforce a lack of diversity in a university. Historically, since most college students were white and upperclass, legacy admissions are likely to be white and upperclass. By definition, they will not be first generation college students.

What universities are ending legacy admissions?

More than 100 colleges and universities have ended legacy preferences since 2015, according to a report from the nonprofit Education Reform Now. That includes the prestigious Wesleyan University and Occidental College, as well as the flagship University of Minnesota system this year.

Why does Harvard like legacy students?

Given how Harvard and other high-status schools have valued legacy students, it's unlikely they will give up the practice easily, even with the Department of Education investigating the practice. These institutions say legacy admissions help foster relationships with alumni and promote an intergenerational community.

How do colleges know if you're a legacy?

Colleges can include questions about legacy status in their supplements on the Common Application, and it's often just two or three questions. Are you related to an alumnus?

Do siblings count as legacy?

Some institutions, such as Stanford and UNC, only consider "primary legacy" status—where one or both applicant's parents are alumni. Yet, most schools will also grant favor to "secondary legacies" who claim a grandparent, sibling, or other non-parental familial affiliation to the school.

Do aunts count as legacy?

An applicant normally has legacy status at a college if a member of the applicant's immediate family attends or attended the college, but at certain schools it might also mean a grandparent, aunt or uncle, or cousin.

How does Harvard know if you are legacy?

A Harvard legacy student is someone with a family tie to Harvard University, often being the child or grandchild of a Harvard alumnus. Legacy status can influence college admissions to varying degrees across different schools, including Harvard, but it's just one aspect considered in the application process.

Does Harvard accept legacy?

Not just Harvard but all Ivy League institutions, considered some of the world's most prestigious, give consideration to legacy status. Other leading institutions, including New York University, Georgetown University, Vassar College and Michigan State University, also follow the practice.

What is the legacy scandal with Harvard?

Harvard is also now the subject of a civil-rights probe by the US Department of Education, after a lawsuit alleged the school gave overwhelming preference to white, wealthy students by prioritising legacy and donor applicants.

What percent of legacy admissions are white?

The complaint argues that legacy admissions are tantamount to racial discrimination because Harvard grants preferential treatment to legacies – 70% of whom are white.

What is the most prestigious Ivy?

For instance, in the U.S News rankings, Princeton is ranked the nation's top college overall, which means that it's also the highest-ranked Ivy League school. On the other hand, Yale is ranked fifth nationally, which is third highest among Ivy League schools.