What is the college scandal on the US News and World Report?

In September 2022, Columbia University acknowledged it had submitted inaccurate data to U.S. News after a math professor at the school called the numbers into question. The incident prompted the media organization to remove Columbia from its 2022 rankings. Columbia, No. 2 before the scandal, is ranked No.

What colleges are pulling out of U.S. News and World Report rankings?

What's wrong with US News College rankings?

In addition, this year's rankings eliminated key measures of academic quality, such as the percentage of faculty who have attained the highest degrees in their fields, the percentage of entering students who are in the top 10 percent of their high school class and average class size.

Why are schools withdrawing from U.S. News and World Report?

Many schools said that the rankings do not accurately reflect their values. The first schools to leave the U.S. News rankings were Harvard Law and Yale Law. Critiques of the methodology include overemphasis on GPA and test scores and a lack of focus on need-based aid and loan forgiveness programs.

What is the Columbia U.S. News controversy?

Early last year, Columbia mathematics professor Michael Thaddeus posted an analysis suggesting the university had misrepresented data across several metrics it provided to U.S. News, including figures related to class size and the share of full-time faculty.

US News & World report college ranking under scrutiny; Columbia admits to providing faulty data

Why is Columbia University not ranked in U.S. News?

We are convinced that synthesizing data into a single U.S. News submission for its Best Colleges rankings does not adequately account for all of the factors that make our undergraduate programs exceptional,” said a letter from Mary C. Boyce, the provost.

Why did Columbia drop in U.S. News rankings?

Thaddeus said he had found discrepancies in the data that Columbia supplied to U.S. News, involving class size and percentage of faculty with terminal degrees — two of the metrics that U.S. News announced it was eliminating from its calculations.

Why are schools boycotting US news rankings?

UCLA and UC Irvine Law Schools are joining the growing boycott of U.S. News & World Report's rankings, saying the methodology the publication uses penalizes institutions that encourage public law careers and seek to enroll students from diverse and marginalized communities.

Why did Harvard withdraw from U.S. News?

Dean writes that his decision is based “on the principled belief that rankings cannot meaningfully reflect the high aspirations for educational excellence.”

Is college worth it U.S. News and World Report?

Investing in college has historically yielded significant benefits, including greater career opportunities, higher earning potential and a better quality of life for millions of Americans. The data has also reinforced the value of a college education, both financially and otherwise.

Is the US News and World Report trustworthy?

Overview. Ad Fontes Media rates US News and World Report in the Middle category of bias and as Reliable, Analysis/Fact Reporting in terms of reliability.

Why did Vanderbilt drop in US news rankings?

The changes in methodology come after top schools — including Vanderbilt Law School — recently opted out of the ranking, stating that it does not align with their values.

What is the most reliable college ranking in the US?

The U.S. News college rankings are viewed as the gold standard of college ranking lists. Its list is the most well-known and referenced. Here is a basic overview of how U.S. News determines its rankings: A total weight of 22% is given to factors related to "outcomes," such as student retention and graduation rates.

What is the top 1 university in US?

What is the fastest rising university in the U.S. News?

"The University of South Florida is proud to achieve our highest-ever position in U.S. News & World Report's rankings and to once again be recognized as America's fastest-rising university,” USF President Rhea Law said.

Why did NYU drop in U.S. News rankings?

According to NYU spokesperson John Beckman, the reliance of the USNWR on past data that did not account for recent university development, explaining for the poor performance of the university on the most recent ranking.

What is the controversy with Harvard?

The president of Harvard University, Claudine Gay, has resigned amid plagiarism accusations and criticism over a congressional hearing during which she was unable to say whether calls for the genocide of Jews on campus would violate the school's conduct policy.

What is the best university in the world for medicine?

Which law school is better Yale or Harvard?

And in 2023/24, Yale Law School is the clear winner ahead of Harvard. Below you can see the results for the top 5 US law schools, with Stanford, NYU and the University of Chicago demonstrating great consistency. The full results of the top 25 US law schools are here.

Which law schools are boycotting U.S. News?

How reliable is U.S. News College ranking?

They accurately reflect the scoring metric in their calculation, except to the extent that some colleges submit fraudulent data. But that doesn't make them meaningful or relevant to you. They're a quick shorthand of the overall resources of the college and are interpreted as prestige.

Why did Harvard law drop in rankings?

We at HLS have made this decision because it has become impossible to reconcile our principles and commitments with the methodology and incentives the U.S. News rankings reflect. This decision was not made lightly and only after considerable deliberation over the past several months.

Is Columbia as prestigious as Harvard?

Any difference in prestige between the two is so small as to be meaningless. No future employer will reject someone for going to one of these universities rather than the other (with slight exceptions for alumni who may favor people who went to their school.)

Is Columbia now more prestigious than Yale?

There is no easy answer when it comes to determining which university is more prestigious, Columbia or Yale. Both schools are highly respected and have a long history of educating some of the most successful people in the world.

Is Columbia more prestigious than NYU?

Is NYU or Columbia more prestigious? Both NYU and Columbia are prestigious universities. Overall, it's harder to get into Columbia. The private institution is also part of the Ivy League.