What is the difference between major revision and reject and resubmit?

Some journals use the term "revise & resubmit" or "reject & resubmit" instead of "major revision". These are all the same thing: they all mean that your paper is not accepted now but you're getting a chance to revise it and get it reviewed again.

Is reject and resubmit the same as major revision?

Reject and Resubmit (or revise and resubmit) (hereafter, R&R) = your article has been rejected. Major revision = your article is in a kind of limbo state where it is neither accepted as is nor rejected but rather held unto the revisions come in.

What is the difference between reject and revise and resubmit?

Reject means we do not want to see the manuscript again. More recently reject and resubmit has become a thing. It is like a revise and resubmit, but the journal is going to count the manuscript as a new submission so their rejection rates go up and the time to final decision goes down.

Can my paper be rejected after major revision?

And you can still be rejected after major revisions; therefore, you need to take particular care.

What does accepted with major revisions mean?

Major Revision – Substantial work is required prior to resubmission. Examples: Substantial rewriting is required. Key elements are missing from the paper or not described in adequate detail, meaning the study is unreproducible and difficult to interpret.

On Peer Reviewing: "Accepting with Major Revisions" vs. "Reject"

What is the difference between major revisions and reject?

Wherein an editor rejects an article but invites you to resubmit later, presumably with what is basically major revisions. Response: Reject and resubmits are situations where the manuscript is rejected, but unlike 'reject' these manuscripts can be modified and resubmitted if appropriate.

What does major revision mean?

So, what does a journal's editorial decision of “major revisions” mean? In short, “major revisions” means you've got work to do on your manuscript, but you're still very much in the game. You had a great research idea to start with. You're not far from getting it accepted and published.

How common are major revisions?

Getting a “major revisions” decision is quite common. In fact, if you don't get a desk reject, then major revisions is the most common decision to expect.

How often are major revisions accepted?

For journals I have managed, the number of “major revision” papers that are eventually accepted stays solidly between 80-90%. When editors, reviewers, and authors have put time into critiquing and improving a paper, it just seems downright unfair to reject the paper.

Should I revise and resubmit?

Just as “Revise and Resubmit” is not a rejection, revising and resubmitting your manuscript isn't a guarantee of acceptance. Some consider a Revise/Resubmit decision as a tacit acceptance, but really there are no promises here, particularly if you are called upon to make major revisions to your manuscript.

What does reject and resubmit means?

Answer: A 'Reject and resubmit' decision is very similar to 'Revise and resubmit. ' It indicates that the editor has seen some merit in your study, but it is not publishable in its current form. Usually, it would require extensive revision, in most cases, adding new experiments or redoing the data analysis.

How do you deal with major revisions?

How common is revise and resubmit?

Getting a revise and resubmit request from a journal may be unnerving, but it is the most common recommendation by peer reviewers across disciplines.

How long does it take for major revision to be accepted after submission?

That in itself will take a bit of time - sometimes the editor doesn't have time to do it immediately, and people could take time to agree. Then, typically I would expect to be allowed at least 2 months (perhaps 3) to check a major revision.

Can you resubmit after rejection?

However, rejection does not mean that your work is worthless or that you should give up on your research. In many cases, you can resubmit your manuscript to the same or a different journal, with some revisions and improvements. Here are some tips on how to do that effectively and increase your chances of acceptance.

What is reconsider after major revisions?

The manuscript may be reconsidered after major revision. This recommendation means that, in a reviewer's opinion, the manuscript in the form presented is not acceptable for publication, but the research is well motivated and the data presented promising.

How do you respond to revise and resubmit?

How long does a major revision take?

Usually reviewers are given 3 months to review a manuscript which has been rendered a "major revision" decision.

What are the 3 stages of revision?

There are three steps to the revision process: revising, editing and proofreading. It is also important to remember that time management is a key factor in the complete process of researching, writing and editing your work. At all stages of the writing process, good time management is essential to success.

Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?

If two reviewers cannot agree on whether to accept or reject a paper, then a third review can be sought. It's unusual to have a rejection after minor revisions. Unless you were antagonistic in your approach to the reviewers, I would suspect the possibility of an administrative error.

What are the two different levels of revision?

So Global Revision makes sure we have a paragraph for each point on our original outline, while Section Revision makes sure that those paragraphs actually do what we want them to do. One of the key components in Section Revision is studying the Topic Sentences of each paragraph.

What is the difference between revision and resubmission?

Here's where it really starts to get complicated. A resubmission (formerly revision) is an amended or revised application that has been previously submitted, but was not funded, and is being resubmitted for new consideration.

How many times can you resubmit on Turnitin?

You are allowed three resubmission attempts where the Similarity Report will generate immediately. After three attempts, you'll have to wait 24 hours before a new Similarity Report can be generated.

What is major and minor revision?

Minor revisions can include many items within the paper that need to be revised, but typically not a major shift or addition to the paper. Major revisions are more substantive and will typically require rethinking some areas of the paper based on the reviewer's comments.

What are the chances of acceptance after minor revision?

For first and second resubmissions, 40.0–55.2% of manuscripts representing a Major Revision and 91.5–94.7% of manuscripts representing a Minor Revision were accepted; 100% of manuscripts undergoing a third resubmission were accepted; 98.3% and 84.7% of manuscripts receiving at first submission a decision of Minor ...