What is the difference between salami slicing and redundant publication?

The Difference Between Redundant and Duplicate Publication: Duplicate Publication is when you publish someone else's work as your own, which is a serious breach of ethics. Salami Slicing is a form of redundant publication where you divide your research into smaller pieces to increase your publication count.

What is salami slicing in redundant publication?

Salami-slicing or divided publishing refers to inappropriate fragmentation of data into the smallest publishable units [1]. The authors opt or seek to publish parts of a study in several papers instead of providing the full story in a single paper [2].

What is the difference between the redundant publication and duplicate publication?

“Duplicate (or redundant) publication” refers to an overlap in the content and authorship of a previously published work. In this case, the contents of the duplicate published work might be nearly identical and have at least one common author.

What is the difference between duplicate publication and salami publication?

Duplicate publication (sometimes referred to as redundant or dual publication) implies reporting identical or very similar data in multiple papers. Salami publication (also known as salami slicing and salami publishing) refers to inappropriate fragmentation of data into the smallest publishable units.

What is a salami publication?

Salami publication or segmented publication is a distinct form of redundant publication which is usually characterized by similarity of hypothesis, methodology or results but not text similarity.

Redundant Publication/Duplicate Publication/Overlapping Publication, Publication and research ethics

What is mean by redundant publication?

Redundant publication (also described as 'salami publishing'): this refers to the situation that one study is split into several parts and submitted to two or more journals. Or the findings have previously been published elsewhere without proper cross-referencing, permission or justification.

What does salami slicing meaning?

salami-slicing | Business English

a series of actions to remove or reduce something by small amounts over a period of time, so that people are less likely to notice any changes: The politicians are already permitting the salami-slicing of the free healthcare principle and no one is protesting.

What are the three types of publication?

Publication types include popular, scholarly, and trade sources. Professors will often assign a minimum or maximum number of sources from each publication type.

How do you prevent salami slicing in research?

“One thing you can do to avoid salami slicing,” said Damian, “is to pre-register all the projects you're planning to do from a specific data set. Then ask yourself, do they use different hypotheses, measures, literatures, etc.” After all is said and done, are they substantively methodically different research papers?

What is the potential consequence of salami slicing for an author's reputation?

Auto-plagiarism and salami-slicing on the other hand may result in rejection and cautioning of the authors but should not automatically result in serious consequences such as those mentioned above. Reuse of authors' own conference abstracts or text from previously published theses is considered acceptable practice.

Why is redundant publication a problem?

First, redundant publication can bias the results of systematic reviews using meta-analysis. Second, multiple publication wastes resources. Third, since academic credit is based on the number of publications, redundant publication may give an unfair advantage to the authors.

What causes redundant publication?

Redundant publication is most likely the result of pressure to publish. Editors call it the “salami slicer syndrome;” au- thors divide their findings from a single study into minimally publishable pieces.

How do you avoid duplicate and redundant publication?

To avoid duplicate or redundant publication, authors need to i) be aware of the practice, ii) appreciate that the practice is wrong and iii) be open with editors when submitting manuscripts for publication especially when in doubt of possible overlap of papers submitted either to same or different journal.

Why is salami slicing considered problematic in research?

Some say it's too much because it dilutes research quality. It's not good for science or for a researcher's career. Salami publishing means dividing your research findings into thin “slices” (like cutting a salami), and publishing each one separately to try to increase your total publication count.

Is salami slicing illegal?

From Longman Business Dictionary saˈlami ˌslicing noun [uncountable]1the illegal act of stealing money from an organization by using a computer to remove extremely small amounts from its financial accounts over a period of timeA number of corporations have been subjected to salami slicing fraud.

What is the purpose of salami?

Salame is primarily served as is, with bread and cheese, for a tasty finger food or a quick lunch. They can also be used in many rustic recipes, to flavor savory pies and casseroles, as a topping for pasta courses or in preparing delicious snacks to be served during happy hour.

What is the difference between peer-reviewed and popular articles?

A scholarly (or academic) resource is one that is written by experts in the field for experts in the field. A popular resource is one that is written for the general public. Your local newspaper is a popular resource. Databases usually have some mechanism to search for only scholarly, or peer reviewed, articles.

What are the two main types of publishing?

These days, book publishing falls under two basic categories: traditional publishing and self-publishing; however, the options for how to publish (or get published) are not quite so succinct. And therefore, the options can be confusing and somewhat daunting. Below is a breakdown of four types of publishing.

What is the difference between popular and scholarly sources?

Popular sources such as magazines and newspapers do not typically go through the same review process as scholarly resources; in many cases, popular resources are reviewed by a single editor, who may or may not have expertise in the subject area.

What is the salami slice problem?

The term Salami Slicing is used often within academia to refer to the needless separation of a single research study, attached dataset, and argument that should form a single publication, into two or several separate publications for submission in different journals.

Why is it called salami?

It's thought to originate in Italy from as far back as Roman times. The word salami comes from the Latin for salt – sale or to salt – salare. Most Southern, Eastern, and Central European countries boast of salami-making traditions that date back several centuries.

Why is it called salami technique?

“Salami tactics” refers to a divide and conquer approach, which aims to split up the opposition. The expression evokes the idea of slicing up one's opposition in the same way as one might slice up a salami.

What is redundant rule?

Redundancy rule is rule which fills in predictable or redundant information. Redundancy rules have two important properties: (a) they do not create structure, and (b) they do not alter structure.

What is multiple redundant or concurrent publication?

Multiple, redundant or concurrent publication

An author should not in general publish manuscripts describing essentially the same research in more than one journal or primary publication. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal concurrently constitutes unethical publishing behaviour and is unacceptable.