What is the review process with editor?

This status indicates that the peer reviewers have completed the review of your revisions and shared the comments with the journal editors. The journal editors will scrutinize the reviewers' comments and run the necessary editorial checks before delivering the final verdict. This process may take up to 3 weeks.

What does with editor for review mean?

Answer: This stage indicates that your paper has not yet been sent for peer review. As per the normal journal processes, the editor first conducts an initial screening of the manuscript. If the manuscript passes this screening, it is sent for peer review.

How long does editor review take?

Editorial Decisions

The handling Academic Editor or staff editor makes the final decision on each manuscript. The time to render a first decision averages about 43 days, but times vary depending on how long it takes for the editor to receive and assess reviews.

What is editor review?

Editorial review is also a part of the peer-review process. Typically editors will take a first pass at an article to determine if it's worthwhile to send out for peer review. They will typically evaluate if the article is: Within the journal's scope. Of sufficient quality to send out to peer review.

What is the difference between under review and with editor?

For most journals, a status change from "With Editor" to "Under review" would indicate that the paper has cleared the editorial check and has been sent for external peer review. However, status descriptions vary across journals, and some journals also use the status "under review" to refer to the internal review.

Elsevier: Submission status explainer

What is the status of with editor after review?

If the status of the manuscript shifted after the peer review to “with editor” or “editor assigned,” it means that the manuscript was returned to the Associate Editor, who will peruse reviewers' feedback and make a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief who makes the final decision (i.e., accepting, rejecting or ...

How long does a manuscript stay with editor?

On average, the length of time it takes an editor to process a paper submitted to their journal and send it out for peer review is 2-3 weeks.

What does your editor expect from you?

Your editor might also ask you to draw out things she thinks deserve more attention or cut things that have already been said to ensure that your work is focused and your ideas are clear. Editing is about commas and semicolons, but it's also about making sure your target audience is your first priority.

Can editor accept a paper without review?

In cases where the work was felt to be of high quality, papers can sometimes be accepted without further review, but if there were serious criticisms, the Editors will consider them in making the decision.

How much should you pay your editor?

Rates for Professional Editing Services. As a guideline, you should expect to pay at least $12 per 1,000 words for proofreading, $25 per 1,000 words for copy editing, and $70 per 1,000 words for content editing or rewriting. As the word count increases, many editing services will charge a lower rate per word.

How long does it take for an editor to make an offer?

If an editor is really enthusiastic about your book, it could take just a couple of days (or even less!). Generally, however, editors need to present the book at their weekly editorial meeting and get their team onboard before they can make an offer. This can take time, sometimes a week or more.

What does awaiting editor review mean?

It means the manuscript has been assigned to an editor and is waiting for the editor to agree to evaluate the manuscript.

What does with the editor mean?

Associate Graduate Faculty, Learning Technologies at. · Jan 4. “with editor” usually means the paper is waiting for the editor to perform an initial screen, and if justified, send out to reviewers. “in process” usually means that the paper is out to reviewers for their comments.

What is the next step after with editor?

If your manuscript status changed to "Seeking Expert Advice" after the "With Editor" stage, it is likely that the Associate editor is in the process of selecting suitable peer reviewers or the manuscript is under peer review, i.e., the status is likely to be in line with the typical "Under Review" status.

Is a letter to the editor a review?

“Letter to the Editor” or “Correspondence” is considered a “post publication peer review”. It is a powerful forum of discussion between the researchers to show the errors and deficits of the study which were overlooked in the pre-publication peer review process.

What is an editor concerned with?

An editor is responsible for reviewing, revising, and correcting written material, such as books, articles, reports, and other forms of written communication. An editor's primary goal is to ensure that the content is accurate, clear, and well-organized, and that it meets the intended audience's needs.

Why was my paper rejected without review?

Sometimes, papers are desk rejected based on their poor writing, with sentences difficult to understand, or simply because they mix methods, results, and discussion or lack reporting essential components of the research.

Do minor revisions go back to reviewers?

Minor revisions explained

An editorial decision of 'minor revisions' on your paper means that your work will almost certainly not be going back to the original peer reviewers for a further round of comments; indeed this is policy for many journals.

Can an editor reject a paper?

Keep in mind, editors reject up to 70% of the manuscripts they receive, so they can be pretty picky. Keep to the format that the journal requests, and this will be one less thing to worry about. Excellent manuscript quality: This is another one that goes without saying.

What do editors look for?

"Plot and character and other aspects obviously matter hugely, but style - particularly if you are a literary publisher - is one of the first places you start." says Simon. "For me, I'm always looking for something fresh, alive, witty, surprising.

How do I prepare for an editor interview?

For editorial roles, as with any creative role, use a portfolio of work samples to jumpstart the conversation. You'll get the most out of your interviews if you can see how their previous work is aligned with the kind of work you want to produce. Editors are also project managers.

How do you respond to an editor?

What does it mean when a manuscript is assigned to an editor?

An Editor-in-Chief is assigned to the manuscript and decides whether to send the manuscript out to review. If the decision is not to send the manuscript for review, the Editor-in-Chief contacts the author with the decision.

What do editors look for in a manuscript?

What are these 'little things' that editors look for? The format, novelty of research subject, brevity, language, clarity, message and quality of presentation do matter for the editors. At submission, the editors consider the relevance of the manuscript for the journal and send it to the appropriate reviewers.

How many pages is a good manuscript?

Non-fiction books are best between 100 to 250 pages (20,000-60,000 words). They should rarely be more than 250 or 300 pages (of course there are always exceptions depending on your target audience) Memoirs can be longer, between 240-520 pages (60,000-130,000 words)