What is the status of with editor after review?

If the status of the manuscript shifted after the peer review to “with editor” or “editor assigned,” it means that the manuscript was returned to the Associate Editor, who will peruse reviewers' feedback and make a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief who makes the final decision (i.e., accepting, rejecting or ...

What is the next step after with editor?

If your manuscript status changed to "Seeking Expert Advice" after the "With Editor" stage, it is likely that the Associate editor is in the process of selecting suitable peer reviewers or the manuscript is under peer review, i.e., the status is likely to be in line with the typical "Under Review" status.

What is editor assigned status after reviews completed?

The status "required reviews completed" back to "editor assigned" indicates that the necessary reviews for a particular task or document have been finished, and the work has been assigned back to the editor for further processing or revisions.

What is the status of article with editor?

With Editor:

This status indicates that an editor has taken charge of the manuscript. At this stage, the editor completes an initial screening of the manuscript, and if he/she finds it suitable for the journal, it is sent for peer review.

How long does it take for editor to make a decision after reviews?

They completed the time to complete a decision about an article after the review process can vary depending on the journal, editor, and reviewers. Some journals have policies in place that require editors to decide within a specific time frame, such as two weeks or a month after the completion of the review process.

Elsevier: Submission status explainer

How long does with editor status last?

Answer: It is perfectly normal for a submission to remain with the editor for over two weeks. The time taken for the different stages varies from journal to journal, but it is not uncommon for the journal system to show a “with editor” status for over a month after submission.

How long does it take for an editor to make an offer?

If an editor is really enthusiastic about your book, it could take just a couple of days (or even less!). Generally, however, editors need to present the book at their weekly editorial meeting and get their team onboard before they can make an offer. This can take time, sometimes a week or more.

How long does a paper stay with editor?

On average, the length of time it takes an editor to process a paper submitted to their journal and send it out for peer review is 2-3 weeks.

What is the difference between under review and with editor?

For most journals, a status change from "With Editor" to "Under review" would indicate that the paper has cleared the editorial check and has been sent for external peer review. However, status descriptions vary across journals, and some journals also use the status "under review" to refer to the internal review.

What is the difference between with editor and decision in process?

Answer: A direct change to Decision Under Process (sometimes, also called Decision in Process) after With Editor means that the editor has had a look at the paper and arrived at a decision on the paper, which is to not send it for peer review.

Does editor decision started mean rejection?

So, yes, such a quick movement from 'With Editor' to 'Decision in Process' usually means it might be a desk reject. However, what you can hope for is that the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who makes the final decision on the manuscript, sees things differently from the associate editor (AE), who has made the initial decision.

What is the difference between editor assigned and with editor?

However, at times, there can be a slight difference between them. In this case, Editor Assigned means, as the name suggests, that an editor has been assigned to your manuscript. With Editor means that your manuscript is/was with the editor undergoing the initial journal review.

What comes after required reviews completed?

The fact that the status changed from "Required Reviews Completed" to "Under Review" could mean that the editor has received all reviews from the reviewers and is currently in the process of making a decision on the manuscript. It could mean that the editor has decided to send the manuscript for additional reviews.

What is the meaning of decision in process after with editor?

Both decision in process and decision in progress mean that the associate editor has submitted your paper to the senior editor. They are currently deciding whether your manuscript is fit for publication in their journal or not. You'll either get an acceptance, rejection, or a request for edits.

What is with editor after peer review?

If the status of the manuscript shifted after the peer review to “with editor” or “editor assigned,” it means that the manuscript was returned to the Associate Editor, who will peruse reviewers' feedback and make a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief who makes the final decision (i.e., accepting, rejecting or ...

What is the status of reviews completed?

Reviews Completed means that the peer review of the manuscript is complete.

Why is my paper under review for so long?

There are several possible reasons for such a delay, e.g., overload of papers under review, difficulty in finding suitable reviewers, and reviewers taking longer than usual owing to their own constraints.

Is a letter to the editor a review?

“Letter to the Editor” or “Correspondence” is considered a “post publication peer review”. It is a powerful forum of discussion between the researchers to show the errors and deficits of the study which were overlooked in the pre-publication peer review process.

Can an editor review a manuscript?

In such cases, the editor himself/herself also does a fairly detailed evaluation of the manuscript to compensate for the lack of another reviewer or asks an associate editor to take responsibility for the paper. Usually, the Associate Editor is an expert in the field/areas covered.

Is it normal that my journal submission is with editor after a month?

The time taken for the different stages in the submission process varies across journals, but it is quite normal for the status to show “With editor” for over a month after initial submission. The reason why this stage can take time is that it is often difficult for the editor to find reviewers.

What does with editor mean in journal submission?

“with editor” usually means the paper is waiting for the editor to perform an initial screen, and if justified, send out to reviewers. “in process” usually means that the paper is out to reviewers for their comments.

Can editor accept a paper without review?

In cases where the work was felt to be of high quality, papers can sometimes be accepted without further review, but if there were serious criticisms, the Editors will consider them in making the decision.

How long is too long to wait for a written offer?

Normally it's within a week. Even with slow reference responses and background check factored in I think 2-3 business days is common. If it's more than a week I would think that they don't really want me and are still debating what to do or that they're unreliable.

Why is my written offer taking so long?

Internal Processes: Companies often have several internal processes and procedures in place that need to be followed before an offer letter can be generated and released. These processes can involve multiple departments, such as HR, legal, and finance, each with their own set of responsibilities and tasks.

What is the average time on submission for a novel?

It happens. But it's absolutely the exception, not the rule. Only about 16% of debut authors receive an offer within 1 month. Those respondents who have not yet sold a book have been on submission for 3 months to two years with the average around 13 months.